The United States Supreme Court on Monday rejected an emergency request from the Trump administration that would have forced California to set aside mail-in ballots cast by about 20,000 registered voters, according to Reuters. Federal officials allege the voters on the list are likely noncitizens. The justices acted only hours after the Justice Department filed its request, one day before the midterm elections that will decide control of Congress.
The court's order was a single sentence, offered no reasoning and recorded no public dissent from any justice, Reuters reported. The justices also did not ask California to respond to the filing, a step the court usually takes when it is giving an emergency request serious consideration. The administration had demanded that the challenged ballots be separated from all others and left uncounted until each voter's citizenship could be verified.
The decision was the third defeat for the administration in the case within a week, USA Today reported. District Judge David Carter refused the Justice Department's request on October 28, describing the election-eve demand as brazen interference, and a divided panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld his ruling on Friday. The appeals court said the federal law against noncitizen voting does not give the department control over how a state runs its elections.
The dispute began over the summer, when federal agencies obtained California voter-roll data and later sent the state a list of names to investigate, according to USA Today. The administration first claimed about 190,000 illegal voters were on the rolls, then revised the figure to roughly 20,000. California officials said the list appeared to be filled with errors, and an analysis by UCLA's Voting Rights Project found that about 42 per cent of the names did not match anyone in the state's voter file.
With the request denied, California will count its ballots under its existing procedures as voting concludes on Tuesday. The state mails a ballot to each of its roughly 23 million registered voters, and election officials said safeguards against noncitizen voting were already in place. The underlying lawsuit continues in the lower courts, but no change to ballot handling will take effect for this election, according to Reuters and USA Today.
Sources: Reuters, USA Today
