A federal judge in Massachusetts on Monday dismissed the Trump administration's lawsuit seeking to force Harvard University to hand over detailed admissions records, according to Inside Higher Ed. Judge Myong J. Joun granted Harvard's motion to dismiss the case without prejudice, ruling that the government had not shown it completed the steps required before asking a court to intervene. The decision leaves the administration free to fix the defects and sue again.
The Justice Department filed the case in February, UPI reported, as part of an investigation into whether Harvard still considers race in admissions after the Supreme Court's 2023 ruling against the university ended race-conscious admissions nationwide. Federal officials sought years of applicant-level files, including grades, test scores, personal essays and admissions outcomes, arguing the data was needed to test compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act.
Joun's ruling turned on procedure rather than the underlying dispute, Inside Higher Ed reported. Under the enforcement framework the government invoked, agencies must first notify an institution that it is out of compliance and determine that voluntary compliance cannot be secured before going to court. The judge found the complaint did not adequately allege those steps, writing that the government had not supplied a sufficient basis for the judicial relief it sought at this stage.
The administration quickly signalled the fight is not over. A Justice Department spokesperson told Inside Higher Ed the court had dismissed the case on a narrow pleading question and invited an amendment, adding that the United States would file an amended complaint. An Education Department spokesperson, Ellen Keast, accused Harvard of well-documented discrimination against teenage applicants and said the university remained obliged, as a federal funding recipient, to produce the information.
Harvard has argued the Justice Department never properly engaged with its objections to the scope and burden of the requests, according to UPI. Joun was explicit that his ruling decides nothing about whether Harvard discriminated, whether agencies may lawfully demand applicant-level data, or whether the university may ultimately have to provide it. The dismissal is the latest chapter in a running legal battle between the administration and the nation's oldest university.
Sources: Inside Higher Ed, UPI
